January 16th, 2021

We’re hostage to resources

By Letter to the Editor on June 5, 2020.

Suppose I inherit a rich uncle’s money: Common sense tells me that I should invest it, and dip into the capital only in an emergency. You live with what you earn. Savings account is for rainy days. Do not plan to live on it. Canada is wealthy thanks to natural resources. But we are taking money out of our inheritance and are living on it.

Canadians are lucky to live in a country with so much natural resources. It is the gifts from God, Mother Nature or whatever. We didn’t earn it. It was given to us. It was here when we got here. Generous original inhabitants of the land allowed us settle here to catch, extract and harvest it.

Settlers worked hard with blood and sweat to grow and raise and dig it out. However, rich soil was here to begin with. We cleared the land and put down seeds. Fossils had already been buried under our feet. What have we been doing with them? We must be grateful and treat them with respect as gifts, not entitlement.

Are we investing it for the future or are we living on it like a spoiled brat? Are we managing it, or harvesting it and driving it into extinction like we did with Atlantic cod and Pacific salmon?

I should also remind ourselves about volatility of resource markets. Unsavoury rulers of the countries like Iran, Russia and Saudi Arabia often make it the weapon against us, like they are doing with oil today. We are vulnerable. We are only waiting for the tide to change direction. It’s humiliating to depend on unpredictable markets.

It’s about time we think seriously about change. Let’s stop fighting people who criticize our way of life. Everyone must try to see other’s points of view. The solution often comes from compromise. Some people argue that coal is almost limitless and oil will last many more decades. Really? I accept their point for now. We still have to buy groceries and pay mortgages while changing our way of life. It’s the cost to finance our transformation.

A resource-based economy is notoriously volatile as the current crisis in oil market testifies. Keystone XL may restart. Bitumen may start flowing over mountains. But it’s only for the measures we take while in transition. Let’s not continue to be a hostage to the unstable resource based economy.

Tadashi (Tad) Mitsui


Share this story:

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Southern Albertan

This brings to mind former Conservative Premier Peter Lougheed’s ‘Six Principles’ for resource development which were, not, followed by subsequent Alberta Conservative right wing politics:
“Behave like an owner, Collect your fair share, Save for a rainy day, Go slow, Add value and Practice Statercraft.”
Likely, we could have had at least $100 billion, if not more, in our Heritage Trust Fund by now, making money on money.
Sadly, and unfortunately for tax paying Albertans, the KXL pipeline is looking to be cancelled by the USA’s Biden if Trump loses the election in November, which now, could be likely. And, unfortunately, as well, the TMX pipeline will likely have to be built to prove that it will not meet expectations.
The downturn in the oil and gas sector has been known to happen, for years, and preparation was not done, except for the Notley AB NDP preparing for economic diversification while supporting oil and gas in the transition. Now, the Kenney UCP is talking diversification!? Out of the AB NDP playbook!?

Fedup Conservative

Southern Albertan has nailed it. Although those of us from the world of finance know the loss to the public is more like $400 billion.

He might want to read this” Misplaced Generosity Alberta government set to forgo an additional $55 billion over the next three years. Add that to the $195 billion we had already lost, plus another $150 billion in tax breaks and that’s where we get the $400. billion


oil is king – i think if we dump several more billions into the industry, so as to line the pockets of the very rich ceos, who in turn line the pockets of politicians and the cons party, that will force the world to want alberta oil. or, maybe if we flavour or carbonate or infuse our oil with pretty colours the world will wake and see what they are missing. alberta oil: let’s make the world want it.