February 11th, 2025

Smith says she knew of no wrongdoings; critics keep pressure on seeing multiple investigations occur


By Anna Smith SOUTHERN ALBERTA NEWSPAPERS Local Journalism Initiative Reporter on February 11, 2025.

Premier Danielle Smith has responded to the allegations surrounding AHS procurement and contracting processes, though Alberta’s NDP and AUPE question if actions taken will be enough.

In a statement on Saturday, Smith said she had “read various media stories containing allegations regarding the procurement and contracting processes of AHS. They are troubling allegations and they should be reviewed as quickly as possible.”

“To that end, I will be writing Auditor General Doug Wylie to ask for an expedited review and his findings on this issue,” said Smith. “I have also directed my officials to ensure that any request for information from Mr. Wylie or his office is dealt with on a fully transparent and expedited basis. We need to get to the bottom of this issue quickly to identify any potential wrongdoing, correct it, and address it appropriately.”

She has also asked for the AHS internal review to be finished quickly and delivered to her, as well as for all contracting of surgical facilities under review to be paused until these findings are delivered.

While she says she has been unhappy with the level and quality of service delivered by AHS, she says that “as Premier, I was not involved in any wrongdoing.”

AUPE vice-president Curtis Jackson however, says the provincial employee union is disappointed by this response.

“These are serious allegations of backroom deals and inappropriate procurement practices,” said Jackson. “This is a scandal, and it’s the biggest one, in my recollection, since Alison Redford was providing her private plane to family members. It’s actually, I would say, even worse.”

He referenced back to the MHCare contract to procure children’s medication from Turkey in 2022, noting that CEO Sam Mraiche was “the fellow who provided luxury box tickets that the Premier and her cabinet ministers used in May 2024,” said Jackson.

While he added that none of these allegations have yet been proven, they have caused a massive break in faith with the union and the provincial government, one that “calls into question literally every decision that this government has made regarding health care over the last year, and that expands into and includes the splintering of health care into independent silos.”

Jackson called for the investigation to be handed over to the RCMP, and for the findings to be made available to the public, as opposed to being delivered to the province first, as he feels this is necessary for transparency in the face of these alleged dealings and questions into the motives behind the “actions of her government to privatize our health-care system.”

The sentiment was echoed by Christina Gray, House Leader of the Official Opposition, as she called for the UCP cabinet to act.

“(Tuesday), the cabinet is meeting and the UCP government must act. As a first step, Premier Danielle Smith and Health Minister Adriana LaGrange should step aside while investigations take place,” said Gray. “The Official Opposition has demanded accountability so that Danielle Smith cannot sweep these allegations under the rug. We have called for full and transparent investigations by the RCMP, the Auditor General and the Ethics Commissioner. A full public inquiry is needed.”

Gray encouraged the rest of the UCP cabinet to “put their cards on the table.”

“Do they stand for this kind of corrupt government, or will they show Albertans any ounce of accountability,” said Gray. “They can make that clear (Tuesday) by demanding the Premier and Minister step aside and allow all required investigations to take place.”

Share this story:

15
-14
Subscribe
Notify of
4 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Kal Itea

Step aside Danielle and Adriana LaGrange, request an investigation run by RCMP NHQ OTTAWA.

Kal Itea

Here is a summary done by Chapt AI of today’s G&Mail story:
Health Services’ (AHS) authority to negotiate contracts with Chartered Surgical Facilities (CSFs). This action followed internal concerns raised by then-CEO Athana Mentzelopoulos regarding the cost-effectiveness of certain CSF contracts.
Key Points:

  • Government Directive: On October 18, 2023, Minister LaGrange declared CSFs as essential to Alberta’s healthcare system and indicated that the health department would assume a more active role in CSF-related matters.
  • CEO Dismissal: Athana Mentzelopoulos was terminated from her position as AHS CEO on January 8, 2025, two days before a scheduled meeting with the Auditor-General concerning her internal investigation into AHS procurement practices.
  • Allegations of Interference: Mentzelopoulos alleged that government officials pressured her to extend a contract with Alberta Surgical Group Ltd. (ASG) and to negotiate new deals in Red Deer and Lethbridge. She expressed discomfort due to the lack of transparency regarding CSF ownership.
  • Contract Negotiations: In October, AHS extended ASG’s contract, reportedly securing lower rates than the original agreement. However, it’s unclear if these terms align with those outlined in the October directive. No contracts have been finalized for the proposed facilities in Red Deer or Lethbridge.
  • Ministerial Directive Details: The October directive instructed AHS to immediately, in consultation with the health department, extend ASG’s contract, specifying the number of procedures and associated costs.
  • Concerns Over Costs: Mentzelopoulos assessed that the rates proposed in the directive were higher than recently negotiated AHS rates, potentially leading to increased costs for AHS and significant profits for CSF owners.
  • Transfer of Negotiation Authority: On December 23, 2024, Chris Nickerson, Alberta Health’s Assistant Deputy Minister overseeing acute care, informed Mentzelopoulos that the department would assume responsibility for due diligence related to CSF procurements, directing AHS to cease its due diligence activities unless otherwise notified.
  • Request for Documentation: Government officials stated that after learning of concerns regarding CSFs, they repeatedly requested documentation from AHS to substantiate these claims. Due to a lack of substantive information after nearly eight months, Minister LaGrange issued a directive in December compelling AHS to share all details related to CSF contracts.
  • Internal Review: Mentzelopoulos initiated an internal review into CSF contracts and procurement. However, the December 23 letter ordered her to halt this investigation.
  • Leadership Changes: The government has made significant changes to AHS leadership, including removing the entire board twice and appointing three different leaders since Premier Danielle Smith took office.
  • Audits and Investigations: Auditor-General Doug Wylie confirmed an ongoing review of AHS contracts, and the RCMP has received related complaints. Premier Smith has requested an expedited review from the Auditor-General, and AHS announced it is conducting its own review.
  • CSF Ownership Transparency: Mentzelopoulos raised concerns about the lack of clarity regarding the ownership of some CSFs, which contributed to her discomfort in proceeding with certain contract negotiations.
  • Government’s Stance: A spokesperson for AHS stated that the extension with ASG secured lower rates for services than the original contract. However, it’s unclear if these terms align with those outlined in the October directive.

These developments have led to calls for independent investigations into the allegations of government interference in AHS procurement processes.

Chmie

Smith’s perception of “wrong doing” and reality are polar opposites. A fully independent inquiry into her interference with AHS process is required to determine if there was any wrong doing.

Sheran.

The understaffing of our healthcare system would not exist if the NDP had not encouraged and enabled drug usage in our province, as they have done in British Columbia. \
Because of the NDP’s poor policies, hundreds of healthcare professionals are forced to work in areas affected by the opioid problem. It has put strain on our courts and prisons, and it has led to shortages in paramedics, firefighters, police, and healthcare.
The NDP blame game is getting old to me!
While they stand in judgment and refuse to look in the mirror, they are responsible for many of the issues we currently face. The NDP continues to promote its ineffective harm reduction policies despite the UCP having already shown concrete evidence that their recovery and treatment plans are effective. Take a look at BC! We would resemble BC if it were not for the UCP.



4
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x