BYU looking to keep momentum building after unexpected quarterback competition

By Canadian Press on August 19, 2025.

BYU entered the offseason with questions at receiver, cornerback, defensive line and kick returning.

Quarterback was not expected to be an issue with Jake Retzlaff likely returning after a solid first season as the Cougars’ starter.

That all changed this summer, when Retzlaff opted to transfer to Tulane while he reportedly faced a suspension for violating BYU’s honor code. Now the Cougars will start a true freshman at quarterback for the first time in program history after Bear Bachmeier edged out two more experienced players.

“We feel good about the talent that we have,” said BYU coach Kalani Sitake, entering his 10th season in Provo. “We have to let them battle it out and see what happens. If you’re going to play quarterback at this level, you have to be a leader already. They’re all natural leaders.”

Retzlaff won a tight competition with Gerry Bohanon to become BYU’s starter last season and got better as the season progressed. Retzlaff threw for nearly 3,000 yards and 20 touchdowns with 12 interceptions, adding 417 yards and six more TDs rushing.

The Cougars finished 11-2 with Retzlaff leading the offense, capping the season with a win over Colorado in the Alamo Bowl.

Retzlaff’s course — and BYU’s with it — changed when he was named in a sexual assault lawsuit earlier this year. The suit was later dismissed, but Retzlaff acknowledged having consensual sex in his defense, a violation of the school’s honor code asking students to abstain from premarital sex.

Retzlaff’s decision to transfer left BYU with three prime candidates to earn the starting job this season: Bachmeier, McCae Hillstead and Treyson Bourguet.

Hillstead played eight games at Utah State in 2023 and Bourguet played 10 games over two seasons at Western Michigan. Both players have a year under their belt at BYU after transferring.

A four-star recruit out of Murrieta, California, Bachmeier did not play at Stanford and transferred to BYU after spring practices, but quickly picked up the offense and was named the starter for the opener on Aug. 30 against Portland State.

“What’s up Cougar Nation, this is QB1 Bear Bachmeier,” Bachmeier said in an X video post of an AI bear wearing his No. 47 jersey while walking through the woods. “Excited to get this season going.”

Martin’s impact

The loss of Retzlaff could give L.J. Martin an even bigger chance to shine in his third season in Provo.

The 6-foot-2, 220-pound running back rushed for 518 yards and four touchdowns in 2023, following that up with 718 yards and seven TDs last season. Martin was named offensive MVP of the Alamo Bowl after accounting for 121 yards and two touchdowns.

Dominating D

BYU had a rare down season defensively in 2022, but bounced back the past two seasons behind coordinator Jay Hill.

The Cougars again should have a formidable defense this year, even after losing several starters on the defensive line.

Linebacker has been a strength in Provo and will likely continue to be with the returns of Jack Kelly and Isaiah Glasker. The front does return several players with experience and the addition of Utah transfer Keanu Tanuvasa should be a big boost.

The secondary lost Jakob Robinson and Marque Collins — also one of the nation’s top kick returners — but has plenty of experience in the back with multiple players who were in the rotation last season.

Schedule

BYU won its first nine games last year and has a chance to get off to another good start in its third Big 12 season.

The Cougars open at home on Aug. 30 against Portland State, with nonconference games against Stanford and at East Carolina. BYU opens conference play at Boulder on Sept. 27, with road games against Arizona, Iowa State, No. 23 Texas Tech and Cincinnati.

The Cougars host rival Utah on Oct. 18.

___

Get poll alerts and updates on the AP Top 25 throughout the season. Sign up here. AP college football: https://apnews.com/hub/ap-top-25-college-football-poll and https://apnews.com/hub/college-football

John Marshall, The Associated Press