The West wants out of Confederation
By Lethbridge Herald on July 27, 2022.
KEN ALLRED
Danielle Smith as a candidate for the leadership of the United Conservative Party has proposed an Alberta Sovereignty Act as her first bill when she is elected Premier. In that light, it is worthwhile to review the history of Alberta and Western Canada that has led up to this moment in our political history.
Back in 1988 I was all for the West Wants In as a candidate for the Reform Party of Canada but now some 33 years later I’m struggling with the future of Western Canada within the Canadian federation. Ever since Confederation, the West has been nothing but a cash cow for the Eastern Establishment.
Rupert’s Land was purchased from the Hudson’s Bay Company for a pittance and right away the federal government moved in on the Métis settlers even before the ink was dry.
The intrusion on Métis lands caused Louis Riel to step on the surveyor’s chain stopping further subdivision of the west. Initially the feds had planned to create 800 acre sections of land but in returning to Ottawa it was decided that more settlers and hence eventually more revenue would come to the federal coffers if they reduced the size to 640 acres or one square mile. That revenue went into federal coffers but little was used to benefit the new settlers.
As the west was settled and Frederick Haultain became the leader of the provisional government for the Northwest Territories, he fought tooth and nail to get sufficient funds from Ottawa to maintain basic government services and finally provincial status for Saskatchewan and Alberta.
Ottawa ignored his recommendations and the Liberal government at the time even denied Haultain, a staunch liberal, an interim premiership.
Ever since Alberta and Saskatchewan became provinces we were robbed of the right of ownership of our natural resources. Finally, after a 25 year struggle, ownership of our natural resources became a reality in 1930.
Ownership of those resources was a godsend in 1947 when Leduc #1 blew in and enhanced the provincial treasuries making the west the envy of Ottawa and Central Canada. But despite the fact that Alberta was generous in loaning money to eastern provinces and generously sharing our wealth, along comes Pierre Trudeau with the National Energy Policy denying us world prices for our oil.
But worse still Trudeau had a hidden agenda to slowly but surely convert our once capitalist society into a socialist state and handing over the balance of power to French speaking bureaucrats.
Western Canada was asleep at the switch when he brought in bilingualism. “Official bilingualism is not about language” as Peter Brimelow stresses in The Patriot Game, “official bilingualism is about political power.” And political power has transformed Canada into a French state run by a French bureaucratic regime.
By repatriating the Constitution from Britain and passing the 1982 Constitution Act, and the Charter of Rights, Pierre Trudeau, with Gerard LaForest as the principal draftsman of the Liberal proposals for constitutional change, transformed forever our system of government, weakening parliamentary democracy by passing the legislative torch to the judiciary.
As Secretary of State Serge Joyal said, “Everything we undertake and everything we are doing to make Canada a French state is part of a venture I have shared for many years with a number of people . . . The idea, the challenge, of making Canada a French country both inside and outside Québec . . . is something a little beyond the ordinary imagination.”
Beyond the ordinary imagination is right, and beyond the realization of English Canada. William Gairdner sums it up nicely in The Trouble With Canada . . . Still when he says: He [Trudeau] wanted to convert our bottom-up, common law-based, piecemeal – and yes, intentionally checkerboard Confederation – into as unitary a State as possible in the monistic French style. And further “the Charter has subjugated the provinces and made them internal colonies of Ottawa.”
As former Prime Minister Brian Mulroney once said: “It is the French dimension of our national personality that constitutes the soul of Canada.”
The West has less than a third of the seats in the House of Commons, less than a quarter of the seats in the Senate and Québec has a guarantee of a third of the seats on the Supreme Court of Canada.
Federal elections are decided before Western Canadians have a chance to count the votes. Ottawa continues to treat the Western Provinces as colonies of the Eastern Establishment.
The French may have lost the battle on the Plains of Abraham but they have won the battle for the francization of Canada.
And now with Trudeau Jr. denying access to shipping bitumen from the West coast and supporting Québec in denying pipelines to the east coast the West is toast!
Over the last seven years of the Trudeau regime, with the federal government continually usurping powers granted to Alberta under section 92 of the Constitution Act, we have been denied any sovereignty we are legally are entitled to. Danielle Smith is the only candidate that has come out forcefully to stand up for those rights that have been taken away from Albertans.
Failing the restoration of those sovereign powers, I would advocate for The West Wants Out!
Ken Allred is a former St. Albert alderman and MLA and a charter member of the Reform Party and inaugural candidate in 1988.
23-22
I continue to regard the Reform Party, and any version of the Federal Conservatives that reflect it (May the Gods forgive us if Pierre Pollievre ever becomes PM) as the greatest threat to Democracy in our Nation.
And that includes the UCP in Alberta (A more conspiracy theory/false fact laden crapwagon cannot be seen anywhere except in Q forums…and Donnie Drumpf’s living room).
You pressing your “trope buttons” doesn’t impress.
Stop trying to finagle your way into becoming an American by trying to fool Canadians.
Because most of your “platform” is built on rotten wood that has been in use in the States for a while now. And that house is falling down in real time.
Your party, and every iteration of it has done more to waste Albertan’s money than anything done by the Fed.
And it’s done more to destroy Canadian Legacy on the World stage (under that Harper guy).
I know that your just blowing hot air for your base; but your base ain’t the only group watching your bullpuckey show.
Totally agree. Quite sick of the perpetual “poor us” syndrome. Canada owes us NOTHING.
The West? According to research B.C. residents are the least interested, in Canada, in independence, 33% of Albertans are, and less yet in Saskatchewan and Manitoba.
“Poll: Independence support higher in Alberta than Quebec”
http://www.westernstandard.news/bc/poll-independece-support-higher-in-alberta-than-in-quebec/article_02a8a17e-fc7c-11ec-9c9f-372eac76d34a.html
So, no, the west, does not have majority sentiments toward independence.
Count me as one who will fight to stay in the confederation. A poll with a leading question means nothing. I love Alberta and I love Canada I’ll just leave it at that.
Only when DS is elected Premier of this Province will Ottawa start take us serious! She has demonstrated some backbone in standing up to the thieves out east and hopefully make his authoritarian government accountable some how.
When she is elected ( sure she will be) hopefully she can put together some kind of mock ballot asking Albertan’s whether or not if it’s beneficial for us to remain in Canada. Guaranteed mock or not the effect of such a question would put us squarely in the center of Ottawa’s radar. GO DANIELLE GO!!!!
Biggest mistake Alberta could make is elect a conspiracy theorist to sit in the premier’s chair but in a way I welcome it because it will guarantee an NDP win in ’23.
“conspiracy theorist?” In what way? The Feds have been shafting this province for years! That’s FACT! Please explain yourself.
I want confederation and an quite sick and tired of the continuous complaining and bashing of the federal government. This narrative has been developed and milked since PET. You’d think the cons in this province who want out would just leave and let the rest of us be Canadian.
What part of Eastern Canada are you from Ron? You are obviously in denial!