February 26th, 2024

Provincial government has a double standard on energy affordability issues


By Lethbridge Herald on November 22, 2023.

Editor:

The UCP government has expressed its concern and disagreement regarding the changes the federal government has announced to temporarily removing its carbon tax on home heating oil.

As reported in a statement to Postmedia, Treasury Board and Finance Minister Nate Horner called on the federal government to make carbon tax exemptions for all fuel types.

“I am happy for Canadians in Atlantic Canada for the break they will be receiving from carbon tax on home heating oil, but I am extremely disappointed that Canadians in Alberta, Saskatchewan and other provinces who heat their homes with natural gas have been neglected,” Horner wrote.

“The federal government needs to step up and cancel the carbon tax or make this exception for every province and every fuel type.” 

Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre on accused Prime Minister Justin Trudeau of creating “two classes” of Canadians by carving out a carbon tax exemption for people who use home heating oil while requiring households using other fuels to pay the levy. 

There is now a debate expected in the House of Commons, introduced by the Conservative Party with support from the NDP asking for similar carve outs on the carbon tax and widening the exemptions to other types of home heating across the country.

The UCP government feels that the Liberal government’s program on heating oil is unfair and inequitable to many Canadians and has a stark parallel to the UCP’s program of electricity rebates where $500 per household was given to Albertan homeowners, small businesses and farms ending in June 2023. While most Albertan homeowners received this rebate from their electricity providers, thousands of condominium owners and tenants in multifamily buildings did not, and still have not received this affordability measure.

Many condominium stakeholders’ groups met with three successive UCP cabinet ministers and several senior staff members to try and get the provincial government to address this issue during the last year and a half and a petition asking for inclusion in this program was presented with over 1000 signatures was presented in the legislature on the last day of the last session. All of this was to no avail.

I can’t help that feel that with all the rhetoric being thrown around ‘affordability’ and different levels of government responsibility that this is there can’t be a more important time for the UCP government to be getting its own affordability house in order before spending so much time playing the victim to another level of government’s inequitable treatment of taxpayers.

I hope to see some resolution to this issue in this legislative session.

Phil Rosenzweig

Lethbridge

Share this story:

15
27
8 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
SophieR

Good points.

Or Justin should take Pierre up on cancelling the heating fuel tax. And also suspend the carbon tax rebate nobody seems to know about. Thereby funnelling more money up to the rich and profligate while abandoning the milquetoast response to climate catastrophe. We all lose, which seems to be the way we like it.

gs172

You have a choice to drive your car, keeping warm not so much. Although it doesn’t show up your electricity bill you’re paying carbon tax on that bill as you can bet the natural gas generators are paying it on the gas. The carbon tax is not revenue neutral as you get charged gst on it. Tax on a tax.

SophieR

Sure, but the families who need the money are getting max rebates:
“The 2023-24 annual (CAI) payment amounts for a family of 4 will range from $976 in Ontario to $1,544 in Alberta.”

The average home in Alberta is paying under $400 in Carbon Tax on heating fuel. (I paid under $300 in the past 12 months). That means a poorer family is much better off with the current tax & redistribute system.

So, rich people are trying to get out of a tax while tricking the gullible many into something that will make poor people poorer. And the elite politicians and ideological think tanks lobby for it in the name of these needy people. Pretty cynical.

I’m no fan of trying to change behaviour through taxes, but our populist rage farmers should at least be honest.

Last edited 3 months ago by SophieR
SophieR

This is good. But 2017 numbers. The tax is now $3.3/GJ. The average home in Alberta usef 120 GJ.

buckwheat

It’s a dead issue Phil. The carbon scam is up. So is “intermittent” power, We’re just late to the send off.

https://joannenova.com.au/2023/10/vw-orders-are-down-50-ford-loses-38000-on-each-car-toyota-chief-says-people-are-waking-up/
https://joannenova.com.au/2023/10/wind-power-investors-abandon-siemens-energy-another-shocking-37-fall/
https://www.newsmax.com/larrybell/ev-electric-vehicles-biden-administration/2023/11/10/id/1141830/
https://www.foxnews.com/opinion/slow-demise-green-energy

Now before all the usuals chime in to denounce the messenger(s) maybe some contradictory factual web sites could be provided. Thanks. I look forward and wait with bated breath the Peter Lougheed and dumb reformer seniors rant. 😂

lumpy

Your holier than thou attitude, condescending tone and garbage links speak a lot about you.