January 19th, 2022

Justice won’t be visible to Albertans when the process is hidden

By Lethbridge Herald on January 14, 2022.


Recent changes arriving within phase 2 of the Alberta Provincial Administrative Penalties Act seek to eliminate the public’s right to challenge traffic charges in open court. Doing so effectively reinforces the current government’s fiscal bottom line securing a lucrative income source through the implementation of what is merely a poorly disguised form of “taxation without representation.”

 As of April 1, 2020, the Alberta government increased its portion of any provincial fine money collected by municipalities from 26.7 to 40 per cent, a walloping 13.3 points. Now it appears the government is intent on expanding their profit margin through the elimination of associated costs relating to open and transparent court proceedings.

I find it more than a mere coincidence that this government has taken steps limiting the purchase of additional photo radar equipment and its installation at new locations, but only until Dec. 1, 2022, all the while touting newly revised parameters as to where and when photo radar may be used – a purely political move whereby the government is seen to give with its right hand, while hoping Albertans won’t notice it will soon be taking even more with the left?  

In effect, Albertans are now being told to like it or lump it – all without recourse to face their accuser or provide sworn testimony regarding the circumstances present and actions taken; arguments previously evaluated by an experienced and impartial member of the Alberta judiciary. Our serving M.L.A.’s should keep in mind the old adage remembering, “Justice must not only be done, but must also be seen to be done,” an important right that will no longer be extended to everyday Albertans when the process is hidden from the eyes of the public.

Stephen Kirk is a retired Sergeant of the Calgary Police Service responsible for supervising day-to-day operations of the Photo Radar Unit during the late 1990’s. A court-accredited traffic collision reconstructionist and breathalyzer technician, Kirk was instrumental in the initial research, costing, and planning of Calgary’s Red Light Safety Initiative.      

Share this story:

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Southern Albertan

Just another Kenney UCP drop-the-ball issue that will have to be reversed when the AB NDP win the next election?

old school

Sadly the NDP are all for this also
easy money,crap on the citizens

Southern Albertan

There is some interesting commentary on what the AB NDP has to say about this new traffic court law in this article, in full:
“The UCP are denying Albertans their right to due process,” said Irfan Sabir, NDP critic for justice.”


Kenney is already tweeting about his so called promise of a balanced budget, the details of which Albertans will be forced to swallow in the upcoming speech from the throne.
Mr. Kirk not only clearly outlines one revenue stream Kenney is using to support his Pied Piper song sheet, he correctly points to the fact that in Alberta, one is presumed guilty vis a vis traffic violations.


the .05 standard and the tape attached to that was already over the top. this is a further tightening of the autocratic screw.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x