July 20th, 2024

Working to ensure you have reliable and affordable electricity


By Lethbridge Herald on October 14, 2023.

AT THE LEGISLATURE
Nathan Neudorf – UCP MLA for Lethbridge East

As we head out of summer and into fall, I know everyone is bracing for their power bills to go up as the temperatures drop.

Coming off a period of record-high prices for the Regulated Rate Option, this is not what anyone wants to hear, nor is it the current direction things are headed.

There is good news on the horizon for everyone in Lethbridge and the rest of the province. 

In the short-term, several natural gas generators are scheduled to come online by the end of the year or early next spring, which will put further downward pressure on the RRO which has already fallen from a high of 32 cents per kilowatt hour in August to 19 cents this month. 

University of Calgary economist Blake Shaffer told CBC News that the added generation should drop the price to below 10 cents in the new year. It’s lowest point since before 2020.

While the opposition points to our inquiry on renewables as adding to the high prices, we were seeing record investment in renewables as prices were skyrocketing. Something is clearly not working in our market and needs to be corrected. 

Since the pause was announced, the number of renewable projects entering the Alberta Utilities Commission queue has actually increased. 

Too be clear, renewable energy is an important part of our grid going forward, the focus is on how to most efficiently integrate it into our grid for the highest benefit to consumers.

I am looking into long-term solutions to reliability and affordability of electricity for all Albertans. 

This means having the right mix of energy sources as well as technology in our overall system management.

I have been busy this past month speaking with groups from across industry and the country looking at different options and technologies.

I spent the first part of last week in southern Ontario where I spoke at the Energy Storage Canada conference and was able to connect with individuals on the development of battery storage. This is an evolving field which does have several players from Alberta. 

The challenge, however, is to find a way to make this technology affordable and more efficient in storing wind and solar generated energy and utilizing its many attributes to optimize our grid and energy consumption.

While in Ontario, I was also given a tour of the Bruce Power nuclear plant and was able to discuss the potential of nuclear energy as part of the mix in Alberta. This is a long-term solution, but the federal regulatory process alone can take as long as 12 years for a new facility before a shovel hits the ground.

I was later recognized at the Ontario Legislative Assembly prior to meeting with Ontario Energy Minister Todd Smith about what they have done and are continuing to do to ensure the reliability of their electricity grid. While Ontario’s grid is run by a Crown corporation, they do have similar challenges on the horizon if thefed’s Clean Electricity Regulation goes forward, especially when it comes to natural gas which is additional baseload power for them.

This was underscored by Ontario’s Independent Electricity System Operator which told the Globe and Mail that Ottawa’s draft regulations do not reflect their input or real-world experience. 

It warns about how the CER will slow the electrification of their economy and compromise the reliability of their grid while increasing electricity costs. In fact, in 2018, the Ontario government cancelled 758 renewables projects to save approximately 12 cents-per-KWh on consumers bills. We are trying to learn from their experience.

This followed on the heels of the Alberta Electricity System Operator holding a rare press conference to warn of the disastrous potential impacts of the CER to the reliability and affordability of Alberta’s grid.

“In order for us to be a reliable electricity system, through time and well into the future, we need to have dispatchable technologies that can meet the demands of the province when, quite frankly, the wind isn’t blowing or the sun isn’t shining,” Mike Law, president of AESO, told the media.

That’s the crux of it all.

We are leaving no stone unturned. I’ve talked with companies, with renewable sector-specific groups, municipalities and landowners – including at the Alberta Power Symposium and the Alberta Municipal Fall Convention.

We’ve talked with jurisdictions from across North America while watching the likes of environmental frontrunners California, Germany and England temporarily backtrack on coal and other thermal generation due to their inability to meet energy demands. The goal is to ensure Albertans have power when they need it most and at a price they can afford, and that is what we are going to do.

Share this story:

24
-23
11 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Southern Albertan

“How ‘economic withholding’ is impacting Albertan’s power bills and why even the premier is watching. Danielle Smith suggests ‘something’s broken’ and needs to be done.”
http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/alberta-electricity-economic-withholding-1.6946797
This market power or offer behavior by the big power generators is well explained by Blake Shaffer in this article.

Southern Albertan

And who removed the cap on electricity prices in Alberta? The UCP. Would the UCP consider reinstating the cap?

buckwheat

The cap was NDP defined. Cost us 100 million. But ssh. No need to mention that.

SophieR

A million homes in the province, $100 relief for each family. Shh. Sounds like what a ‘cap’ does.

buckwheat

Yep and you have no problem sharing your wealth do you, Someone needs to create wealth to keep the parasites happy. In the words of your fearless leader, put on a sweater just an update, Neufeld is dreaming on the battery storage front.

https://www.manhattancontrarian.com/blog/2023-6-29-world-now-wasting-more-than-1-trillion-per-year-on-investing-in-useless-renewables

Last edited 9 months ago by buckwheat
SophieR

Nice, SA.

Economic Withholding – allowing the electricity generators to fleece the public, while blaming one specific past government for high prices. Meanwhile, we send a team of politicians around the world to validate their already formed ideology.

I hope that someone on Team Alberta understands the urgency of reducing emissions immediately, and not kick the can down the road to a techno-utopian thorium future.

buckwheat

So what is the preferred number in your humble opinion as to the ppm of CO2. What is the goal.

SophieR

The safe target, based on science (that is, experiment supported by empirical evidence) is described here:
https://mn350.org/understanding350/
What’s missing, but important, is the 30 year or so lag between emission and impact – which means the disruption we are seeing today was dialed in 30 years ago.

buckwheat

Where did they go?? Haven’t heard from this cult for years. Must have been another guess.
after trillions spent on the green machine we are around 420. What’s the solution to “fix” natural viability now that Greta may have discovered Boys.

Last edited 9 months ago by buckwheat
SophieR

Didn’t really think you were serious about learning anything.
The scientists know the numbers, the investments are woefully shy of anything recommended (like the stern report two decades ago). It’s grim, buckwheat, even if you think it is a joke.

biff

the real cost to electric and gas comes with the numerous fixed fees charged to users. it is outrageous that the oligopolies are permitted to end run caps on electric and gas, and whatever other illusions the govt of the day conjures up for the emasculated public, with sundry fixed fees that amount to far more charges than the rate of usage. for this we can thank the nasty klein; for this we can also thank the cons and ndp, neither of which have done anything to return to our wealth and energy to the people of alberta.
then again, we get the governance we are willing to tolerate, and it seems the masses here are all too fine enough allowing a relative handful sleaze the masses.